Longwood 7, St. John the Baptist 6: Steven Mandery scored on a fielder’s choice in the sixth and gave Longwood a 7-4 lead in non- league. Kevin Watkins’ three-run home run and Matt Monastero’s solo homer in the first gave Longwood a 4-0 lead. March 30
| Sachem East 10 Longwood 0 |
| WP – Wilson. LP – Talbot. March 31, 2005 |
| Floyd 9 Longwood 3 |
| WP – Squires. LP – Dinis. HR – L 1 (McAleese). April 5 |
| Floyd 10 Longwood 4 |
| WP – Cabrera. LP – Egloff. April 6 |
| Longwood 7 Brentwood 5 |
| WP – Talbot. LP – Mahoney. HR – L 1 (Weeks). April 6 |
| Longwood 7 Floyd 6 |
| WP – Brewster. LP – Ruiz. April 7 |
Longwood 7, Floyd 6: Anthony Borriello’s RBI fielder’s choice capped a three-run sixth for Longwood (1-2). Floyd is 4-2. April 8
| Longwood 11 Mattituck 1 |
| WP – Deos. LP – Claire. HR – L 3 (McSherry 2, McAleese). April 10 |
Longwood 11, Mattituck 1: Ryan McSherry hit two home runs, including a grand slam, for Longwood in the other first-round game. Tim Deos pitched five innings and allowed no runs and one hit with eight strikeouts. April 10
| Smithtown 12 Longwood 3 |
WP – Saluzzi. LP – Dinis. HR – S 2 (M. Joyce, Hunsucker); L 1 (Monastero). April 12c
| Smithtown 9 Longwood 0 |
| WP – Herron. LP – Egloff. Matt Herron fanned 10 in a five-hitter for Smithtown (5-3 Suffolk League I). Longwood is 1-4. April 13 Smithtown 5 Longwood 3 WP – Gilroy. LP – Brewster. April 14 |
Longwood 16 Shoreham-Wading River 11, WP – McSherry. LP – N/A. HR – L 2 (Deos, McAleese). April 17
Longwood 8 Lindenhurst 4, WP – Dinis. LP – Corbett. HR – Lo 3 (McSherry, Monastero, Watkins). Ryan McSherry’s three-run homer in the fifth put Longwood (2-5 Suffolk League I) up 6-4. Two batters later, Kevin Watkins hit a two-run homer. Lindenhurst is 2-8. April 19
Longwood 12 Lindenhurst 5, WP – Brewster. LP – Asaro. HR – Lo 1 (McSherry). April 20c
Longwood 6 Lindenhurst 3, WP – Deos. LP – Pensa. HR – Lo 2 (McAleese, Watkins).
Patchogue-Medford 7, Longwood 6: Matt Herrick’s bases-loaded single drove in Joe Izzo in the eighth for Patchogue (8-2). Longwood is 4-6. WP – DiPresso. LP – McSherry. April 26
Patchogue-Medford 5, Longwood 1: T.J. Phelan allowed a run, three hits and one walk and struck out nine for Patchogue (9-2 Suffolk League I). Longwood is 4-7. April 27 WP – Phelan. LP – Brewster. HR – PM 1 (Stephan).
Patchogue-Medford 10 Longwood 7, WP – Raimondi. LP – Deos. HR – PM 2 (Cody, Perez); LW 2 (Monastero, Mandery). April 29
Sachem East 4 Longwood 3, WP – DeMaeo. LP – Dinis. May 3
Sachem East 4 Longwood 2, WP – Mikalsen. LP – Brewster. HR – SE 2 (Luchsinger, Neubauer) L 1 (McSherry).
Sachem East 9 Longwood 6, WP – Luchsinger. LP – Deos. HR – SE 3 (Aguiar, Neubauer, Schreiber); L (Borriello). May 5
Longwood 14 Brentwood 6, WP – Egloff. LP – Valle. HR – L 2 (McAleese, Watkins). May 10
Brentwood 8 Longwood 6, WP – Terrero. LP – Brewster. HR – B 2 (Blouin, Vasquez); L 2 (Monestero, Mandary). May 11
Longwood 5 Brentwood 0, WP – Deos. LP – Bargellini. HR – L 1 (Monastero). May 13